The T2K collaboration has submitted our first physics paper to Physical Review Letters. In it we report the most significant evidence to date that muon neutrinos transform into electron neutrinos. This transformation is governed by a previously unmeasured parameter of nature (called θ13 “theta one three”). In this paper we report the detection of six electron neutrino events in a carefully controlled beam that should have at most 1.5 electron neutrino events. The probability that we observe as many as six by chance is less than one percent. The publication of this result is accompanied by a press release from the Japanese laboratories and a seminar at KEK.
A graphical event display of one of the six electron neutrino events recorded by the Super-Kamiokande detector. The numerous colored circles represent which of the 11,100 photomultiplier tubes was struck by cherenkov light.
Map of Japan showing the T2K neutrino beam.
The T2K experiment sends a beam of neutrinos produced at the J-PARC accelerator on the east coast of Japan 295 kilometers (through the earth’s crust) to the Super-Kamiokande detector in the Kamioka mine on the west side of Japan. The beam is actually mis-aimed slightly, a trick known as the “off-axis technique”, to select neutrinos of a specific energy. The energy is precisely tuned to match the neutrino oscillation effect discovered by Super-Kamiokande in 1998 using neutrinos from cosmic rays. When the beam arrives at Super-Kamiokande, the neutrino oscillation effect is maximized and most of the muon neutrinos disappear. However, if the θ13 parameter is not zero (from prior experiments we already know it is small), we can detect a few muon neutrinos turning into electron neutrinos. Based on these six events we can say with modest confidence that θ13 is greater than zero, but it is not statistically certain enough to claim a discovery.
Testing custom ethernet cards at B.U. Mike Litos, undergraduate Brian Henning, and Jen Raaf.
Boston University has been involved in the Japan physics program since 1991. We helped construct the original Super-Kamiokande detector, with major responsibility for the outer detector. Our group has graduated seven Ph.D.s and provided research opportunities for a number of undergraduates. Our most recent effort, with the help of the B.U. Electronics Design Facility, was to build custom ethernet readout cards for the 2008 Super-Kamiokande electronics upgrade, which completely replaced the the electronics and data acquisition for the detector in time for the T2K phase of operation. Boston University authors on this first paper include graduate student Mike Litos, research associate Jen Raaf, and Profs. Ed Kearns, Jim Stone, and Larry Sulak. Our research efforts are supported by the Department of Energy Office of Science.
Measuring the θ13 parameter is the major objective of numerous experiments world-wide. Several experiments use nuclear reactors as a source of electron neutrinos: the Double Chooz experiment in France, the Daya Bay experiment in China, and the RENO experiment in Korea. In the U.S. there are accelerator-based experiments that use a neutrino beam from Fermilab to Minnesota. The MINOS experiment, designed for other purposes, is also searching for electron neutrino appearance. The NOvA experiment will use the off-axis technique with a new detector under construction. Boston University neutrino group alumnus Mark Messier, now a professor at Indiana, is the co-spokesperson of NOvA. Alumnus Wei Wang is a research scientist at William and Mary, looking for θ13 with the Daya Bay reactor experiment. Alumna Fanny Dufour is a co-author on this T2K paper, but is now working as a research scientist at the Université de Genève, Switzerland. We continue to closely collaborate with our past research associates Chris Walter and Kate Scholberg, who run their own Super-K/T2K group at Duke University. Past research associate Alec Habig is a professor at University of Minnesota Duluth working on MINOS and NOvA.
If the results from T2K and all of these experiments firmly establish that θ13 is not zero, then we have nearly completed our description of the neutrino sector of the standard model. If θ13 is large enough, this opens the door for a future generation of experiments to explore the remaining open questions, in particular, the difference between neutrinos and their antiparticles (antineutrinos). This difference in behavior is referred to as CP violation. It is of great theoretical interest to fully understand CP violation in the hopes of explaining why the observed universe is composed of matter and not equal parts of matter and antimatter. Future projects, such as the proposed Fermilab-Homestake Long Baseline Neutrino Oscillation Experiment (LBNE) will seek CP violation with neutrinos, but need a sizeable value of θ13 to proceed. Another possible project would use an upgraded J-PARC neutrino beam, still pointed towards Kamioka, but with a massive new detector called Hyper-Kamiokande.
The T2K experiment started in January 2010 and was running smoothly until interrupted by the great Japan earthquake on March 11, 2011. The published result is based on all of the accumulated data through that date, but that represents only 2% of the planned exposure of the experiment. There was no damage to the Super-Kamiokande detector in west Japan, but the J-PARC accelerator complex experienced quite a bit of damage to infrastructure. Roads were buckled and pipes and connections were broken, but it seems so far that damage to accelerator components was minimal. It will take concerted effort to get the J-PARC complex back online; work is underway and we anticipate resuming the neutrino beam in late 2011.
Ed Kearns
Relative locations of Super-K, J-PARC, and the epicenter of the 2011 earthquake.
